So much fun!
I got some great entries, both here and on Facebook, so I had a friend pick a number at random and the winner is:
Congrats, Maia! Contact me off-blog and I'll get your prize to you, which is a bag of See's Candy Sour Hearts, in honor of the holiday. :) Hope you enjoy!
And thanks to everyone who participated! Your stories provided so much fun and enjoyment, and gave me something humorous to share when people asked "what happened?"